OAD Likes and Dislikes
Child Survival Technical Support


Nov-20-08

Workshops
Mini
M & E
Planning
Technical
BCC
Features
Search Our Site
Site Map
Workshop/Meeting Registration
CS Web Links
Contact Us




Child Survival Technical Support

About CSTS Documents Projects Tools CSTS Workshops


Documents - Workshop

PVO Contributions to Sustainable Child Health:

Recommendations and Next Steps for Evaluation, Learning and Advocacy

Participant "Likes" and "Dislikes" of the OAD as Proposed

Likes

  • The way the user is able to choose--can bring out some things not previously thought about
  • There’s an open menu
  • Integrated approach; will help you select how to pick indicators
  • Guidance through capacity building of organization/community, especially with indicators
  • Incorporates flexibility in defining indicators; Incorporates flexibility where consensus is open (i.e. institutional strengthening and stringent where consensus is agreed upon (such as Measles and Rapid CATCH indicators)
  • Good in the long term
  • Access to anyone with Internet
  • Global health could invest more in strengthening PVOs/NGOs and the local partners--shows that small PVOs/NGOs are more genuine players.
  • Abstract things that are hard to be quantified can be better represented
  • Online assistant good for headquarters staff
  • Very comprehensive tool
  • Indicator categorization
  • Presents opportunity to synthesize and present findings (sustainability change)
  • It's a working tool--additions can be added (indicators, etc.)
  • Includes evaluation tools and plans
  • Good attempt to highlight value of components
  • Potential to provide empowerment at the community level
  • Captured all major components of a complex issue
  • Provides mechanism to get successes out
  • Forum to better share ideas

Dislikes

  • Confusion on first presentation
  • Not so hot in the short term: It is another tool. It requires more training and some amount of manpower and time commitment on the part of the NGO
  • Requires technology and a modem
  • Question the length of time in measuring
  • Need to somehow evaluate what is going on 5-10 years down the line
  • Need to spend more time studying/understanding the model
  • Don't like the name (it's a mouthful!)
  • Labor intensive
  • Will probably require external facilitator
  • Items may be subjective

Back to main page


 


 CSTS+ Project/Macro International
 Phone: 301-572-0823
 Email: csts@macrointernational.com


 CORE          PVO NGO Community          CSHGP